Pumpkin Ice Cream Pies, Fall Treats & Family-Favourite Desserts

This Thanksgiving, bring the dessert everyone will talk about. From our famous Pumpkin Ice Cream Pies to fall-inspired sundaes and handcrafted cakes, Merla-Mae helps you serve something unexpected — and unforgettable.

Order Cakes Online
Pumpkin ice cream pie with a glossy amber top and a rim of whipped cream rosettes dusted with cinnamon, one wedge cut to show the filling, on a cream plate against pale blue, at Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario

Fall favourites at Merla-Mae

Pumpkin Spice & Everything Nice

Thanksgiving is the season of comfort and flavour — and at Merla-Mae, we’re scooping both. Try our creamy Pumpkin Spice sundaes, Maple Walnut milkshakes, and fall-exclusive soft-serve creations.

And don’t miss our signature Pumpkin Ice Cream Pies — layered with spiced ice cream, crushed graham or cookie crusts, and topped with whipped cream and festive toppings.

From our recent fall menus

  • Pumpkin Spice Caramel Crumble
  • Pumpkin Spice Biscoff Parfait
  • Pumpkin Cinnamon Shake
Soft-serve sundae with crunchy cinnamon squares and a caramel-layered soft-serve parfait beside cinnamon sticks, at Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario

Ideas for your table

Thanksgiving Dessert Inspiration

Take a peek at past fall favourites — from pumpkin pies to caramel-drizzled cones and maple fudge sundaes. Whether you’re bringing dessert or treating yourself post-dinner, Merla-Mae makes Thanksgiving extra sweet.

Whole pumpkin ice cream pie dusted with cinnamon and ringed with whipped cream rosettes, from Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario

Pumpkin Ice Cream Pie

Dusted with cinnamon and ringed with whipped cream rosettes. See our cakes & pies
Apple Dandy sundae with hot caramel and cinnamon on soft-serve in a homemade waffle dish at Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario

Apple Dandy Sundae

Apple square, hot caramel & cinnamon. See all our sundaes
Turtle sundae with hot caramel poured over chocolate sauce and turtle mix at Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario

Turtle Sundae

Hot caramel, chocolate sauce & turtle mix. More premium sundaes

Seasonal flavours rotate, so call or stop in to see what’s in the freezer this fall.

Plan ahead for Thanksgiving

Pre-Order Your Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream Pie or Classic Fall Cake

Looking for a unique dessert to wow your guests? Our seasonal ice cream cakes and pies are made with real pumpkin, smooth soft serve, and fall toppings like toffee crunch, graham crumble, and spiced caramel. Choose from classic round cakes, slab sizes, or our Thanksgiving-exclusive pumpkin ice cream pies.

Tip: These sell out fast, so pre-order early.

Pre-Order Your Fall Dessert
See all our cakes & pies
Turtle ice cream cake cut open to show its pecan, cookie crumb and chocolate layers, topped with caramel and pecans beside autumn maple leaves, from Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario

Happy Thanksgiving

Give thanks. Make it Merla-Mae.

Show up with the best treat at the table. Our fall desserts are made fresh, full of seasonal flavour, and perfect for sharing.

Order Cakes Online See All Cakes & Pies