Ice Cream Cakes & Pies – Made to Order

Each ice cream cake and pie at Merla-Mae is handcrafted with premium ice cream, rich layers, and over-the-top flavour combinations. Choose from our in-store favourites or work with us to create something completely custom for your celebration.

Perfect for birthdays, milestones, holidays, and everything in between.

Order Cakes Online

Call (519) 438-CAKE

Three ice cream cones with colorful toppings, a small decorated cake, and several bowls of candies and sprinkles on a white surface.

Portrait Cakes

A truly personal ice cream cake.

Turn your favourite photo into an edible keepsake. Simply bring in or email us your image, and we’ll print it onto a special edible paper, then build a custom ice cream cake around it.

Choose your size, flavours, and decorations — the result is a stunning, one-of-a-kind cake made fresh for your occasion.

Ideal for birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, and special surprises.

Close-up view of a birthday cake with frosting, decorative flowers, and gold star sprinkles, featuring a photograph of a young girl on its surface.
Decorative round cake with green, yellow, and black icing, featuring an image of a building with colorful lights and neon sign, on a white plate.

Birthday Cakes

Because birthdays deserve better cake.

From simple and classic to colourful and bold, our birthday ice cream cakes are made to match your style. Choose your flavours, colours, decorations, and toppings — balloons, sprinkles, chocolate accents, or something totally custom.

With endless combinations available, we’ll make sure your birthday cake tastes just as good as it looks.

A round birthday cake with white frosting, decorated with colorful sprinkles around the edges, featuring three small fondant figures in red, blue, and green on top, placed on a white cake stand.
A slice of birthday cake with white frosting, decorated with blue, pink, and green icing, on a black plate with pink and beige icing borders, a gold spoon, and a white pitcher of chocolate syrup, against a pink background with a blurred dessert and green plant in a pot.

Ice Cream Pies – A Merla-Mae Favorite

Not just cake lovers welcome.
Our ice cream pies are rich, indulgent, and made fresh with the same care as our cakes — just in a slice-able, show-stopping format.

Some of our most loved flavors include:

  • Skor® Ice Cream Pie – crunchy Skor pieces folded into creamy ice cream with a chocolate base

  • Turtle Ice Cream Pie – chocolate, caramel, and pecans layered for a classic, decadent bite

  • Very Berry Cheesecake Pie – a fan favorite with a smooth cheesecake base and bright berry flavor

Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, bringing dessert to a gathering, or just want something different from a traditional cake, our ice cream pies deliver big flavor in every slice.

Flavors vary and custom options are available — ask in-store or contact us to order.

A cheesecake with a chocolate and caramel topping, decorated with chocolate shavings and crumbs, with a wedge cut out and placed on a white plate.
A partially sliced berry cheesecake on a white plate, decorated with cherries, blueberries, whipped cream, and crushed cookies, with additional berries on a cracked gray surface nearby.

Endless Flavour Options

Built your way, every time.

Pick from popular favourites like Oreo®, Reese’s Pieces®, Skor®, Snickers®, Turtle®, Smarties®, or go beyond with combinations like Pecan Brownie, Banana Royale, Fudge Crunch, Very Berry Cheesecake, Mint Oreo®, and more.

Have a specific flavour in mind? Just ask. If it’s ice cream, we’ll do our best to make it happen.

A round pink cake decorated with strawberries, cream, and chocolate, with a slice cut out revealing layered cake inside. It is on a white platter with a chocolate piped border and garnished with small green leaves.
A heart-shaped chocolate cake decorated with dark chocolate icing, chocolate curls, and small chocolate pieces, with purple flowers on the side.
A slice of cookies and cream ice cream cake topped with crushed Oreo cookies and Oreo cookie pieces on a white plate with a pink background.

Seasonal Specialties

Flavours that change with the calendar.

Throughout the year, we offer seasonal ice cream cakes and pies inspired by the moment — from pumpkin and fall spices to peppermint, festive classics, and limited-time creations.

Seasonal designs and flavours rotate regularly, making each visit a chance to discover something new.

Chocolate and vanilla cake decorated with chocolate fragments, nuts, and gold-wrapped chocolates on top.
A slice of caramel pie with whipped cream and cinnamon on top, on a white plate.
A partially sliced layered ice cream cake with chocolate, caramel, and vanilla flavors, decorated with whipped cream and pecans on top, on a white plate against a pastel pink background.

Allergy-Friendly Options Available

We also offer peanut-free allergy and gluten-free ice cream cakes and pies upon request. Let our team know your needs when ordering, and we’ll guide you through the best options available.

Ready to Order Your Cake or Pie?

Whether you know exactly what you want or need help designing the perfect dessert, we’re here to help.

Visit Us Today
Order Online