Ice Cream Cakes & Pies, Made to Order

Each ice cream cake and pie at Merla-Mae is handcrafted with premium ice cream, rich layers, and over-the-top flavour combinations. Choose from our in-store favourites or work with us to create something completely custom for your celebration. Perfect for birthdays, milestones, holidays, and everything in between.

Order Cakes Online Call (519) 438-CAKE

Turtle ice cream cake cut open to show a chocolate ice cream base, a cookie crunch layer and vanilla ice cream with pecans, topped with caramel, pecans and whipped cream, at Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario

A truly personal ice cream cake

Portrait Cakes

Turn your favourite photo into an edible keepsake.

1Bring in or email us your image
2We print it onto a special edible paper
3We build a custom ice cream cake around it

Choose your size, flavours, and decorations — the result is a stunning, one-of-a-kind cake made fresh for your occasion.

Ideal for

Birthdays
Anniversaries
Graduations
Special surprises

Order a portrait cake online

Portrait ice cream cake printed with a night photo of the Merla-Mae storefront, framed in yellow and green icing, from Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario

Because birthdays deserve better cake

Birthday Cakes

From simple and classic to colourful and bold, our birthday ice cream cakes are made to match your style. Choose your flavours, colours, decorations, and toppings — balloons, sprinkles, chocolate accents, or something totally custom.

With endless combinations available, we’ll make sure your birthday cake tastes just as good as it looks.

Order a birthday cake online

Birthday ice cream cake decorated with piped balloons and a blue icing border, surrounded by cones, gummy worms and candy toppings at Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario

Sliceable & show-stopping

Ice Cream Pies, a Merla-Mae Favourite

Not just cake lovers welcome. Our ice cream pies are rich, indulgent, and made fresh with the same care as our cakes — just in a slice-able, show-stopping format.

Some of our most loved flavours include:

Skor® Ice Cream Pie

Crunchy Skor pieces folded into creamy ice cream with a chocolate base.

Turtle Ice Cream Pie

Chocolate, caramel, and pecans layered for a classic, decadent bite.

Slice of Very Berry Cheesecake ice cream pie swirled with berries and topped with whipped cream at Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario

Very Berry Cheesecake Pie

A fan favourite with a smooth cheesecake base and bright berry flavour.

Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, bringing dessert to a gathering, or just want something different from a traditional cake, our ice cream pies deliver big flavour in every slice.

Flavours vary and custom options are available — ask in-store or contact us to order.

Built your way, every time

Endless Flavour Options

Pick from popular favourites like Oreo®, Reese’s Pieces®, Skor®, Snickers®, Turtle®, Smarties®, or go beyond with combinations like Pecan Brownie, Banana Royale, Fudge Crunch, Very Berry Cheesecake, Mint Oreo®, and more.

Have a specific flavour in mind? Just ask. If it’s ice cream, we’ll do our best to make it happen.

Build your cake online

Oreo ice cream cake on a cake stand with Oreo cookies on top at Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario

Pink ice cream cake topped with chocolate-dipped strawberries and whipped cream at Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario

Square chocolate ice cream cake with piped chocolate icing and chocolate pieces at Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario

Flavours that change with the calendar

Seasonal Specialties

Throughout the year, we offer seasonal ice cream cakes and pies inspired by the moment — from pumpkin and fall spices to peppermint, festive classics, and limited-time creations.

Pumpkin ice cream pie with whipped cream rosettes and a slice cut out at Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario — Pumpkin pie for fall

Easter bunny ice cream cake with piped pink ears and pastel candies at Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario — Easter bunny cake

Heart-shaped Happy Mother’s Day ice cream cake with pink icing roses at Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario — Mother’s Day cake

Happy Father’s Day ice cream cake with a blue necktie design and chocolate drizzle at Merla-Mae Ice Cream in London, Ontario — Father’s Day cake

Seasonal designs and flavours rotate regularly, making each visit a chance to discover something new.

Good to know

Allergy-Friendly Options Available

We also offer peanut-free and gluten-free ice cream cakes and pies upon request. Let our team know your needs when ordering, and we’ll guide you through the best options available.

Read our allergy safety information

Parties & catering

Cakes & Pies for a Crowd

Ordering for a birthday party, the office or a family get-together? Tell us your date and headcount, and we’ll help you choose.

Slab cakes for big groups. A small slab serves 25–30, and a large slab serves 35–40+.
Ice cream pies to share. Turtle, Skor®, Very Berry Cheesecake and more.
More treats on the side. Hand-made ice cream sandwiches by the 6-pack, and soft-serve or hard scoop in litre tubs.