Order Custom Ice Cream Cakes or Pies Online
Build your custom ice cream cake using our easy order form. We’ll follow up with your price and everything you need to know. From flavours and fillings to photos and decorations, your cake will be as unique as your celebration.
How ordering works
How to Order Your Custom Cake
- 1Build your cake in the order form: size, flavour, borders, decorations and message
- 2We follow up with your price and everything you need to know
- 3Pick it up at the shop, any time after 11:00 am
Final pricing is confirmed after we review your order details. Orders placed through the form need at least 24 hours’ notice.
Adding a photo?
Serves 3 to 40+
Choose Your Cake Size
From a 6″ heart for a small celebration to a large slab for a crowd, there’s a size for every occasion. Here’s how many people each one serves.
- 6″ Heart
- Serves 3–4
- Baby Round
- Serves 3–4
- Tear Drop
- Serves 5–7
- Small Square
- Serves 6–8
- Small Log
- Serves 8–10
- Small Round
- Serves 8–10
- Large Round
- Serves 12–14
- 9″ Heart
- Serves 12–14
- Large Square
- Serves 15–20
- Small Slab
- Serves 25–30
- Large Slab
- Serves 35–40+
Built in layers
Cake Flavour Profile Descriptions
Each Merla-Mae cake is built in layers for flavour, texture, and balance. Use the descriptions below to choose your perfect combination.
Merla-Mae’s Original Cake
- Bottom layer
- Chocolate Ice Cream
- Middle layer
- Fudge Sauce & Chocolate Cookie Crunch
- Top layer
- Vanilla Ice Cream
Merla-Mae’s Original Deluxe
- Bottom layer
- Chocolate Ice Cream
- Middle layer
- Fudge Sauce & Chocolate Cookie Crunch (Thicker Layer)
- Top layer
- Vanilla Ice Cream
Oreo Cake
- Bottom layer
- Chocolate Ice Cream
- Middle layer
- Fudge Sauce & Chocolate Cookie Crunch
- Top layer
- Merla-Mae’s Oreo Vanilla Ice Cream Mix
- Decoration
- OREO Cookies
Turtle Cake
- Bottom layer
- Chocolate Ice Cream
- Middle layer
- Fudge Sauce & Chocolate Cookie Crunch
- Top layer
- Merla-Mae’s Turtle Vanilla Ice Cream Mix
- Decoration
- Turtle Chocolates & Caramel Design
Skor Cake
- Bottom layer
- Chocolate Ice Cream
- Middle layer
- Fudge Sauce & Chocolate Cookie Crunch
- Top layer
- Merla-Mae’s Skor Vanilla Ice Cream Mix
- Decoration
- Skor & Caramel Sauce Design
Pralines & Cream Cake
- Bottom layer
- Vanilla Ice Cream
- Middle layer
- Caramel Sauce & Pecans
- Top layer
- Merla-Mae’s Caramel & Pecan Vanilla Ice Cream Mix
- Decoration
- Pecans & Caramel Sauce Design
Verry Berry Cake
- Bottom layer
- Vanilla Ice Cream
- Middle layer
- Marshmallow Sauce & Graham Crunch
- Top layer
- Merla-Mae’s Strawberry & Raspberry Vanilla Ice Cream Mix
- Decoration
- Mixed Berries
Strawberry Cake
- Bottom layer
- Vanilla Ice Cream
- Middle layer
- Strawberry Puree & Shortbread Crunch
- Top layer
- Merla-Mae’s Strawberry Ice Cream Mix
- Decoration
- Strawberry
Allergies? List them in the order form. We also offer peanut-free and gluten-free ice cream cakes upon request.
The order form
Start Your Cake Order
Select your size, flavour, and decorations below. If you’re unsure about anything, just choose your best option, and we’ll follow up.
Good to know
Need a Cake in a Hurry?
We offer a variety of ready-made ice cream cakes and pies available in-store daily — perfect for birthdays, holidays, and last-minute celebrations.
In a time crunch? Contact us directly — in many cases, we can prepare your custom cake within 3–4 hours.
Custom & made to order
Create Your Own Cake
Something you’re looking for that’s not listed? Contact us, and we’ll make it happen!