Ice Cream Cakes & Pies

Each ice cream cake & pie is handmade at Merla Mae. Choose from our everyday favorites or custom-made to your match taste preference and style.

Merla-Mae Ice Cream Portrait Cake
Merla-Mae Ice Cream Skor Pie
Merla-Mae Ice Cream Portrait Cake
Merla-Mae Ice Cream Cake
Merla-Mae Ice Cream Cake Slices
Merla-Mae Ice Cream Turtle Cake
Merla-Mae Ice Cream Neapolitan Cake

Ice Cream Cakes & Pies - Made To Order

A birthday cake with a printed edible photo of a young girl in a dress, surrounded by white, pink, and brown frosting flowers, green leaves, and gold sprinkles, with the message "Happy Birthday"

Portrait Cakes

A perfect gift for any occasion!
Bring in or email us your favorite photo and we print it on a special edible paper. Choose the size and flavor; a stunning ice cream cake with your image will be made fresh for your occasion.

A slice of layered dessert with white and chocolate layers on a dark gray plate, decorated with blue, green, and white frosting, pink rosette frosting along the edge, and a gold spoon on a purple table. In the background, a small pitcher of syrup, a plate with another slice of cake, and a potted plant are visible.

Birthday Cakes

Your Birthday Cake couldn’t taste better!
Balloons or flowers, sprinkles or chocolate, red or blue; the choice is yours, and with tons of options, we’ll make sure your birthday cake is perfect.

A partially sliced berry cheesecake on a gray plate and platter, decorated with whipped cream, berries, and cookie crumbs, with scattered berries around on a cracked gray surface.

Endless Options

Delicious choices for every ice cream lover.
Choose from classics like OREO, Reese’s Pieces, Snickers, Turtle & SKOR to Peanut Butter or the Verry Berry Cheesecake. If those don’t cut it~ build your own!

A caramel topped pumpkin flavored ice cream pie with a slice removed, topped with whipped cream, on a white plate. In the background, a slice of ice cream pie with whipped cream, a small white pitcher, and autumn leaves.

Seasonal Specialties

Flavors that fit every time of the year!
From pumpkin to peppermint, we have all the ice cream flavor profiles that will make your guests drool for more!

Delicious ice cream cakes and pies: Pick from our in-stock fresh-made options or order your custom-made flavor.

Favorite flavors like Oreo®, Caramilk®, Skor®, Oh Henry®, Snickers®, Smarties®, Crispy Crunch®, Turtles®, Reese’s Pieces®, Pecan Brownie, Banana Royale, Banana Split, Fudge Crunch, Caramel Crumble, Grasshopper, French Mint, Butterscotch Ripple, Avalanche, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Pumpkin, Assorted Cheesecake, Caramel Cashew, Pralines’n Crème, Toasted Coconut, Verry Berry, Mocha Almond, Rocky Road, Apple Dandy, Amaretto, Decadent Fudge, Mint Chocolate Chip, Mint Oreo,… you get the point, let us know your favorite flavors and we will make it happen!

Merla-Mae has the flavors, and every option is wonderfully delicious. We also offer peanut-free allergy and gluten-free ice cream cakes and pies upon request.