Handmade Ice Cream Sundaes – Classic Toppings & Creamy Soft Serve

For more than 65 years, we’ve been serving up classic ice cream sundaes with rich toppings, creamy soft-serve, and that timeless retro charm. From the first scoop to the final cherry on top, our sundaes are handmade with care — a nostalgic treat that never goes out of style.

Apple Dandy - With a swirl soft serve in waffle bowl with Merla-Mae cup
Strawberry shortcake sundae with soft serve and cheesecake cubes
Hot fudge sundae topped with whipped cream, cherry, and coconut flakes
Fudge-&-White-Chocolate-Chip-Sundae-Merla-Mae-Ice-Cream.png
Peanutbutter-Delight-Sundae-Merla-Mae-Ice-Cream.png
Rocky-Road-Sundae-Merla-Mae-Ice-Cream.png
Sundae-Merla-Mae-Ice-Cream.png
Turtle-Sundae-Merla-Mae-Ice-Cream.png
Classic banana split sundae topped with whipped cream, cherries, and crushed peanuts

Ice Cream Sundae Menu – 30+ Handmade Flavors & Signature Toppings

Made fresh to order, our soft-serve sundaes are topped with real ingredients and signature sauces — with more than 30 flavors and combos to discover.

If you’ve been to Merla-Mae, you’ve likely spotted our hand-drawn sundae menu — packed with retro favorites and modern creations alike. Our fan-favorite sundaes include the Apple Dandy, Hot Rocky Road, Beam Me Up, New York Cheesecake, and the iconic Banana Split — each one made with rich toppings and our signature creamy soft-serve.

And that’s just the beginning — we serve 30+ ice cream sundae varieties you won’t find anywhere else.

From chocolatey indulgence to fruity classics, here are just a few of the Merla-Mae exclusive sundaes our customers love:

  • Classics: Chocolate, Butterscotch, Pineapple, Strawberry, Cherry, Raspberry, Marshmallow

  • Fruity Favorites: Bumble Berry, Blueberry, Verry Berry, Strawberry Shortcake, Bumble Crumble

  • Signature Creations: Polka Dot, Rainbow Brite, French Mint, Grasshopper, Avalanche

  • Chocolate Lovers’ Picks: Rocky Mountain, Hot Fudge, Fudge Delight, Mocha Almond Fudge, Amaretto Fudge, Decadent Fudge

  • Caramel Craze: Hot Caramel, Caramel Cabaret, Caramel Cashew, Caramel Crumble

  • Nutty & Crunchy: Toasted Coconut, Peanut Butter, Pecan Brownie Fudge, Macadamia Fudge, Hot Fudge Crunch

  • Originals: Beam Me Up 🚀, Banana Royale 🍌, Plain Jane, Tin Roof

We make every sundae to order — ask our team about your perfect combination!